Debbie Potts Coaching

Should you fast or exercise for Cell Autophagy?

Should you fast for cell autophagy if you are fit and active?

This has been a huge question the last few years.  

  1. To eat or not to eat before your morning workout
  2. To intermittent fast 16 hours to burn more fat and rest digestive system
  3. Fasting 17 hours or more for cell autophagy

Does exercise create similar benefits as fasting for cell autophagy?

Yes, both exercise and fasting have been associated with the stimulation of cell autophagy and mitophagy, which are cellular processes involved in the removal and recycling of damaged cellular components, including organelles like mitochondria.
However, it’s important to note that the specific effects may vary based on the type, duration, and intensity of exercise, as well as the nature of the fasting regimen.

Exercise and Autophagy:

  1. Endurance Exercise: Endurance or aerobic exercise has been shown to activate autophagy. This type of exercise, such as running or cycling, can induce cellular stress and energy depletion, leading to the activation of AMP-activated protein kinase (AMPK) and inhibition of mTOR, both of which are associated with autophagy.
  2. Resistance Training: Resistance or strength training also influences autophagy, particularly through the mechanical stress placed on muscles. The cellular response to this stress involves the activation of signaling pathways that regulate autophagy.

Fasting and Autophagy:

  1. Caloric Restriction: Fasting or caloric restriction, especially intermittent fasting, has been linked to increased autophagy. During periods of fasting, cells may experience energy depletion, leading to AMPK activation and mTOR inhibition, which are conducive to autophagy.
  2. Nutrient Sensing Pathways: Fasting also influences nutrient sensing pathways such as insulin and insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF-1), which can modulate autophagy.

Mitophagy:

Mitophagy specifically refers to the selective removal of damaged or dysfunctional mitochondria. Both exercise and fasting have been associated with promoting mitophagy:

  1. Exercise-Induced Mitophagy: Exercise, especially endurance exercise, can lead to the generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) and mitochondrial stress, triggering mitophagy as a mechanism to remove damaged mitochondria.
  2. Fasting-Induced Mitophagy: During fasting, the cell’s need for energy may increase, and the selective removal of damaged mitochondria becomes crucial. Mitophagy is part of the cellular response to maintain efficient energy production.

Synergistic Effects:

There is evidence to suggest that combining exercise with intermittent fasting may have synergistic effects on autophagy and mitochondrial health. However, it’s essential to approach both exercise and fasting in a balanced and individualized manner, as excessive stress or prolonged deprivation can have negative consequences.

In conclusion, both exercise and fasting can promote autophagy and mitophagy through various mechanisms. The specific benefits may depend on the type and intensity of exercise, the nature of the fasting regimen, and individual factors. As always, it’s advisable to consult with healthcare professionals or fitness experts before making significant changes to your exercise or dietary routine.

What type, intensity and duration of exercise is best to produce cell autophagy? Mitophagy?

Exercise has been associated with the induction of cell autophagy and mitophagy, which are cellular processes involved in the removal and recycling of damaged cellular components, including mitochondria. However, the specific type, intensity, and duration of exercise that are most effective for promoting autophagy and mitophagy may vary. Here are some general considerations:

Exercise for Autophagy:

  1. Type of Exercise:
    • Endurance Exercise: Activities such as running, cycling, or swimming, which involve sustained aerobic efforts, have been linked to increased autophagy.
    • Resistance Training: Strength or resistance training, which places mechanical stress on muscles, has also been associated with autophagy.
  2. Intensity:
    • Moderate to High Intensity: Some studies suggest that moderate to high-intensity exercise may be more effective in inducing autophagy compared to low-intensity exercise. However, the optimal intensity may depend on individual fitness levels and overall health.
  3. Duration:
    • Varied Duration: Autophagy can be activated during both short-duration and longer-duration exercise. High-intensity interval training (HIIT) has also been studied for its potential to induce autophagy.

Exercise for Mitophagy:

  1. Endurance Exercise:
    • Aerobic Activities: Endurance exercise, particularly aerobic activities, has been shown to induce mitophagy. The increased demand for energy during aerobic exercise may lead to mitochondrial stress and subsequent removal of damaged mitochondria.
  2. Intensity:
    • Varied Intensity: Both moderate and high-intensity endurance exercise have been associated with the induction of mitophagy. The level of intensity may influence the degree of mitochondrial stress.
  3. Duration:
    • Prolonged Duration: Some research suggests that longer-duration endurance exercise may be more effective in promoting mitophagy. However, shorter-duration, high-intensity efforts can also contribute.

Important Considerations:

  1. Individual Variability: Responses to exercise can vary among individuals. Factors such as age, fitness level, and overall health can influence the cellular responses to exercise.
  2. Consistency: Regular, consistent exercise is likely more important than the specific details of any single session. Establishing a routine that includes a variety of exercise types and intensities may be beneficial.
  3. Nutritional Support: Proper nutrition, including post-exercise nutrition, plays a role in supporting cellular processes. Adequate protein intake, for example, is essential for muscle repair and turnover.
  4. Recovery: Giving the body sufficient time for recovery between exercise sessions is crucial. Overtraining can have negative effects on cellular health.

It’s important to note that research in this field is ongoing, and new findings may provide additional insights into the specific mechanisms by which exercise influences autophagy and mitophagy. As always, individuals should consider their own health status and consult with healthcare or fitness professionals before making significant changes to their exercise routines.

Does too much fasting and AMPK pathway create loss of muscle- catabolic vs. anabolic impacting muscle health, aging and longevity?
Yes, excessive fasting and prolonged activation of the AMPK (AMP-activated protein kinase) pathway can potentially have negative effects on muscle health and may contribute to a catabolic state. The AMPK pathway is a cellular energy sensor that becomes activated in response to low energy levels, such as during fasting or low-calorie conditions. While AMPK activation has several health benefits, chronic and extreme activation may lead to muscle protein breakdown and loss of muscle mass.Here are some considerations:

AMPK and Muscle Health:

  1. Catabolic Effects: Activated AMPK promotes catabolic processes, including the breakdown of glucose and fatty acids for energy. This catabolic state can extend to the breakdown of muscle proteins if energy demands are not met through other sources.
  2. Inhibition of mTOR: AMPK activation inhibits the mammalian target of rapamycin (mTOR), a key regulator of protein synthesis and anabolic processes. Reduced mTOR activity can contribute to decreased muscle protein synthesis.

Impact on Aging and Longevity:

  1. Sarcopenia: Loss of muscle mass and strength, a condition known as sarcopenia, is associated with aging. Excessive catabolism due to prolonged AMPK activation may contribute to the development or acceleration of sarcopenia.
  2. Longevity: While intermittent fasting and moderate activation of AMPK may have positive effects on longevity through mechanisms like autophagy, chronic activation leading to excessive muscle breakdown might have detrimental effects on overall health and longevity.

Balancing AMPK Activation:

  1. Moderation is Key: It’s crucial to emphasize that moderate activation of AMPK is generally considered beneficial for metabolic health. Short-term fasting or intermittent fasting can activate AMPK and induce autophagy without causing excessive muscle loss.
  2. Protein Intake: Adequate protein intake, especially during periods of fasting, is important to support muscle health. Protein provides the amino acids necessary for muscle protein synthesis.
  3. Balanced Lifestyle: Combining intermittent fasting with regular exercise, including both aerobic and resistance training, can help maintain muscle mass and support overall health.

Individual Variation:

  1. Genetic and Individual Factors: Responses to fasting and AMPK activation can vary among individuals due to genetic factors, overall health, and lifestyle.
  2. Consultation with Professionals: Before adopting any fasting or dietary regimen that involves prolonged periods of calorie restriction, it’s advisable to consult with healthcare or nutrition professionals, especially for individuals with existing health conditions or concerns about muscle health.

In summary, while moderate activation of the AMPK pathway through practices like intermittent fasting can have positive effects on health and longevity, excessive and prolonged activation may lead to muscle loss.

Striking a balance through a well-rounded approach that includes proper nutrition, regular exercise, and intermittent fasting in a controlled manner is key to promoting overall health while minimizing potential negative effects on muscle mass.

Which is better option for longevity- intermittent fasting or exercise?

The relationship between longevity and interventions like intermittent fasting and exercise is complex, and the optimal approach may depend on individual factors and lifestyle preferences. Both intermittent fasting and exercise have been associated with potential health benefits related to longevity, and some people may find that a combination of both strategies works best for them.

Here’s a brief overview of FASTING vs. EXERCISE for cell autophagy:

Intermittent Fasting:

Intermittent fasting involves cycling between periods of eating and fasting. Several variations exist, including the 16/8 method (16 hours of fasting, 8 hours of eating) and alternate-day fasting. Benefits associated with intermittent fasting include:

  1. Improved Metabolic Health: Intermittent fasting has been linked to improved insulin sensitivity, reduced inflammation, and better metabolic health.
  2. Cellular Repair and Autophagy: Fasting periods may stimulate cellular repair processes, including autophagy, which is the removal of damaged cellular components.
  3. Weight Management: Intermittent fasting can contribute to weight loss and weight maintenance, which are factors associated with improved health and longevity.

Exercise:

Regular physical activity, including both aerobic and resistance exercise, has numerous health benefits. Exercise is associated with:

  1. Cardiovascular Health: Regular exercise can improve cardiovascular health, reduce the risk of heart disease, and contribute to overall cardiovascular fitness.
  2. Muscle and Bone Health: Resistance training helps maintain muscle mass and bone density, which are crucial for overall mobility and health.
  3. Metabolic Benefits: Exercise improves insulin sensitivity, regulates blood glucose levels, and supports metabolic health.
  4. Mental Health: Physical activity is linked to improved cognitive function, reduced stress, and better mental well-being.

Combination Approach:

Some studies suggest that a combination of intermittent fasting and exercise may have synergistic effects on health and longevity. For example, exercising during the fasting period might enhance the metabolic benefits of both interventions.

Individual Considerations:

The effectiveness of either approach may vary among individuals based on factors such as age, existing health conditions, and personal preferences. It’s crucial to choose an approach that aligns with individual lifestyles and is sustainable in the long term.

Consultation with Healthcare Professionals:

Before making significant changes to your diet or exercise routine, it’s advisable to consult with healthcare professionals or nutrition experts, especially if you have pre-existing health conditions.

In summary, both intermittent fasting and exercise offer potential benefits for longevity, and the most effective strategy may involve a combination of both, tailored to individual needs and preferences. Consistency and adherence to a healthy lifestyle are key factors in promoting overall well-being and longevity.

Does exercise stimulate cell autophagy?  What type of exercise is best?

Exercise has been associated with the activation of a process called autophagy, which is a cellular mechanism responsible for the removal and recycling of damaged or dysfunctional cellular components. While the exact mechanisms are not fully understood, several factors related to exercise may contribute to the induction of autophagy:

  1. Energy Depletion: Intense exercise can lead to energy depletion within cells. This energy deficit can activate AMP-activated protein kinase (AMPK), a cellular energy sensor. Activated AMPK, in turn, can stimulate autophagy.
  2. Mitochondrial Stress: Exercise can cause stress to the mitochondria, which are the energy-producing organelles in cells. Mitochondrial dysfunction or damage can trigger autophagy as a mechanism to remove and replace damaged mitochondria.
  3. ROS Production: Reactive oxygen species (ROS) are generated during exercise due to increased metabolic activity. While high levels of ROS can be harmful, moderate levels may act as signaling molecules that induce autophagy.
  4. mTOR Inhibition: The mammalian target of rapamycin (mTOR) is a protein kinase that regulates cell growth and metabolism. Inhibition of mTOR is a key trigger for autophagy. Exercise, especially endurance exercise, has been shown to suppress mTOR activity, promoting autophagy.
  5. Protein Turnover: Exercise, particularly resistance training, stimulates protein synthesis and breakdown. This process of protein turnover is regulated by autophagy. The removal of old or damaged proteins is essential for maintaining cellular function and structure.

It’s important to note that the relationship between exercise and autophagy is complex, and the specific effects may vary based on factors such as the type, intensity, and duration of exercise, as well as individual differences in genetics and overall health.

Research in this field is ongoing, and new findings may provide further insights into the mechanisms by which exercise influences autophagy.

If we stimulate AMPK pathway via fasting… wouldn’t we impact muscle protein synthesis by blocking MTOR?

The relationship between mTOR (mechanistic target of rapamycin) and AMPK (AMP-activated protein kinase) in the context of autophagy and muscle mass is complex. Both pathways play crucial roles in cellular metabolism, including the regulation of autophagy and protein synthesis.

Here’s a simplified breakdown:

  1. mTOR and Muscle Protein Synthesis:
    • mTOR is a central regulator of protein synthesis and cell growth. When mTOR is activated, it promotes protein synthesis and inhibits autophagy.
    • In the context of muscle, activation of mTOR is associated with muscle protein synthesis, leading to muscle growth (hypertrophy).
  2. AMPK and Autophagy:
    • AMPK, on the other hand, is activated in response to cellular energy depletion. It acts as an energy sensor and, when activated, stimulates processes that generate ATP (cellular energy).
    • AMPK activation is often associated with the induction of autophagy, which can be seen as a catabolic process breaking down cellular components to generate energy.
  3. Exercise and the Balance Between Anabolism and Catabolism:
    • Exercise, especially resistance training, can activate both mTOR (anabolic) and AMPK (catabolic) pathways to varying degrees. The balance between these pathways is dynamic and depends on factors such as exercise intensity, duration, and type.
    • The acute activation of autophagy during and after exercise may contribute to the removal of damaged cellular components.
  4. Impact on Muscle Mass:
    • Chronic, excessive activation of autophagy and suppression of mTOR might contribute to muscle protein breakdown and potentially impact muscle mass negatively. This is particularly relevant if the catabolic processes (AMPK-mediated) dominate over the anabolic processes (mTOR-mediated) for an extended period.

In summary, while both mTOR and AMPK pathways are involved in the regulation of autophagy and muscle protein synthesis, the overall impact on muscle mass depends on the balance between anabolic and catabolic processes. Acute activation of autophagy during exercise is a normal and necessary process for cellular maintenance, but long-term imbalance may have negative effects on muscle mass. It’s essential to consider the context and balance between anabolism and catabolism for a comprehensive understanding of the effects of these pathways on muscle. Individual factors, including the type and intensity of exercise, nutrition, and overall health, also play significant roles in this complex interplay.

Let’s talk about exercise vs. fasting when it comes to triggering autophagy.

Autophagy is a condition. It’s the recycling of old worn-out cell parts. It’s a condition that’s very good for the body.

Autophagy is all about anti-aging. When we age, we have a deficiency of autophagy. Autophagy is also very deficient in chronic disease states. So, it’s very important to know how to trigger autophagy.

The suppression of glucose with the increase of ketones is what triggers autophagy. This is why fasting is probably the most potent thing to trigger autophagy.

But, exercise can also trigger autophagy. Exercise forces the body to use up glucose, and it helps increase insulin sensitivity. When you exercise, you lower insulin. When insulin becomes too high, it can knock you out of autophagy. It can be very beneficial to exercise while fasting because you have a compounding effect.

The autophagy that’s created when you exercise will only last until the next time you eat. Compared to if you fast for 48 hours, you’re getting a massive amount of autophagy.

When it comes to exercise, the amount of autophagy you’re going to get is going to be related to the intensity and the volume of exercise you do. A strong, resistant type workout with high intensity and a good amount of volume can give you more autophagy. But, a low-intense endurance type workout while fasting can enhance the autophagy you’re getting from fasting.

https://www.drberg.com/blog/autophagy-exercise-vs-fasting

Is intermittent fasting necessary if you are fit and active?

Robb Wolf has talked about this concept for sometime now…

Consider this example: If your one and only purpose is to live as long as possible, there will be implications from the IF information that will make for some compelling arguments.

Optimizing lifespan (in the IF scheme this seems to be feast one day, fast one day) will likely by extension bring Health (an acute measure of longevity) near optimization, but Performance may suffer.

Eating one day and fasting one day may not yield elite athleticism. One may be able to be quite good, but perhaps not elite and this is the similarity of altering the pressure/temperature conditions to shift the triple point to a different emphasis of solid, liquid or gas. I think it is obvious that some may desire to optimize performance and the pursuit of performance may necessitate levels of activity (wrestler Dan Gable does not get around so well on his very worn knees) and food consumption that are not conducive to longevity.

Some degree of IF should still aid performance, but it may be different in duration and frequency than the person looking for maximum longevity.

Please just keep in mind that we try to present material that is germane to as broad an audience as possible and in such a way that people can make decisions about how best to implement a given technology to their betterment. It is not for me or anyone else to put forth dictates as to how (or why) to live or what the goals of the individual should be.

…my goal is to find an optimized nutritional protocol for Performance, Health and Longevity.

A key feature of both optimum performance and “effective” aging is a reserve of muscle mass. The IF protocol, as mentioned previously, does not leave the organism in an emaciated state.

Simple energy balance seems to account for most of this, as the IF animals consume on average the same amount as the ad-libitum controls and consequently do not lose weight.

Add to this the finding that IF improves body composition and that IF with a low carbohydrate diet improves it even further.

We also have an increase in IGF and neuroendocrine response to exercise.8. All of this bodes well for muscle mass and performance.

https://www.performancemenu.com/article/20/Intermittent-Fasting/

The stronger you are, ideally the harder it will be to kill you.

The stronger you are the faster you will get yourself out of a hospital bed should you ever find yourself there.

The stronger you are the less likely you will hit that medic alert button because you have fallen and cannot get up.

Strength and Conditioning in the Aging Athlete

Strength and Power:

Rippetoe said it best, stronger people are harder to kill, and more useful in general. Whichever program you follow or gym that you choose to go to, there should be some type of periodized strength and power program built in. While strength gains may be harder to come by, continuing to build strength as well as maintaining strength is extremely important. The stronger you are, ideally the harder it will be to kill you. The stronger you are the faster you will get yourself out of a hospital bed should you ever find yourself there. The stronger you are the less likely you will hit that medic alert button because you have fallen and cannot get up.

While one should focus on building strength, constantly stressing the body with absolute strength tests may not be necessary and ill advised. The ability of the body to handle max effort lifts week in and week out may be extremely stressful, and recovery could be difficult depending on life variables. It is important to make sure the volume and intensity of any strength program is measured appropriately by someone who understands you, your goals, and your life situation. Undulating periodized strength programs I feel have hit the mark in this regard for the aging athlete. Ashman Strength Systems Protocol or the Cube Method are variations of a cyclical undulating periodized system where the volume of maximal efforts between lifts is considered.

 

Hypertrophy:

Along with general strength there should be some focus on building up lean muscle mass. The more lean muscle mass you have the more metabolically active tissue you have, ideally the less fat you have, and the hardier you are. You lose muscle when you age, when you are diseased (older you get more likely), and if you are inactive (Get old, get diseased, becoming inactive for a period of time is more likely). The more lean muscle you carry at 40 means the more you will carry when you are 50 and 60 given you focus on staying active and eating a nutrient dense diet. The more muscle mass you have at 60, the better the outcome if you are laid up in a hospital bed for a week or two. Strength work alone will give some hypertrophy, but exercises and/or rep ranges to encourage hypertrophy should be included. In many strength and conditioning programs, including the two I previously mentioned above, hypertrophy ranges are found in the accessory work. With CrossFit, many of the metabolic conditioning work, aka WODs, have higher rep ranges which skirt the hypertrophy range and could be useful in this regard, in conjunction with a strength program.

Kinesthetic Awareness:

While it may not apply yet to a 40 year old athlete, balance is something one loses as they age. The stronger and more powerful you are the more it helps in regard to balance, however, more awareness of our bodies as they travel through time and space is important. It is important to maintain your body’s awareness of the space around it through training. This has a huge carryover in my mind, and the practice of balancing should be incorporated into all training programs for older athletes. Along with the practice of balancing, the incorporation of static holds is something which also should be utilized, as it engages and strengthens the stabilizing muscles of joints, as well as strengthens the connective tissue in our joints. The practice of balancing while walking (on a beam? a fallen tree?), being upside down, getting up from the floor using our hands as well as not using our hands, holding ourselves in a plank, etc, all has tremendous potential to decrease injury, as well as increase longevity in any training program.

 

Mobility:

Not every joint should be mobile. Some joints help to maintain stability, others need to be mobile through a specific range of motion. Mobilization of the joints which are meant to be mobile through their full ranges of motion is important as it helps prevent injury, from which recovery from takes longer the older you are (Connective tissue injuries as they are heal very slowly). Making sure that the joints which are supposed to maintain stability do so, also is important to prevent injury, and static holds are useful for this. Another key piece to the mobility/stability puzzle in my opinion is making sure there are no muscle imbalances between left and right side. Incorporating unilateral exercises into any training program to address and prevent muscle imbalance is also an important piece of the puzzle. I particularly like kettlebell specific exercises like the turkish get up, kb windmills, single leg deadlifts to work on preventing/fixing left/right muscle imbalances. Many of these exercises are great to incorporate into a warm up regimen or as accessory work.

 

Aerobic capacity:

Basic aerobic capacity decreases 1% every year after 25. By being physically active you help to slow the age related declines in VO2 max. There are many ways that aerobic capacity can be tackled, and its good to mix up the energy systems being worked. There has been a general trend to focus on interval training at the expense of longer aerobic training, however, I feel it is important to include all modalities of training, and not just focus on glycolytic training for optimal health and longevity. Going for a longer walk, swim, bike ride, etc at an easier pace for a longer period of time (over 30 minutes) is not detrimental but helpful in obtaining optimal health and aerobic capacity, just as incorporating some sprints or HIIT into your training regimen is equally important.

The need for a distinctive training program for older athletes is that these athletes have several variables which younger athletes in their prime do not necessarily need to worry about, or the effects of these variables is in a different light. The first of these variables is physiological. Hormonally, the older one is the more different their natural hormone profiles are from their prime. Hormonal levels are greatly involved with the ability to handle training/exercise as a good stress, and recover from those sessions. While recovery is an important aspect of any training program, regardless of ones age, however, in a Master’s level, it may be even more so. Male hormone (Vitamin T) levels start dropping off after age 30 at a rate of ~1% a year. This drop off, combined with already below normal testosterone levels in the general US population to begin with could be problematic for older male athletes. Females over 35 also have changing hormone levels which could affect their recovery as well.

Another variable as one ages is the number of potential stressors actually changes as you age. Older athletes typically have or are involved in career jobs, have a set number of bills, ie mortgage, car payments, school bills, due each month, marriage concerns, children and concerns revolving around the kids, etc. The more stressors, the greater the effects of these stressors on the ability to handle training as well as the ability to recover. The more stress, the greater effect on hormones, which potentially compounds the effects of age on hormone levels.

Enhancing Longevity and sustainability in training

  1. Sleep: First and foremost, you want to have more optimal hormone levels, recover faster, achieve optimal health, live longer, etc, you need to sleep uninterrupted for 7-8 hours.
  2. Focus on eating a Nutrient Dense Diet of non-processed foods. Perfect place to start is with a Paleo diet, and then use that as a template.
  3. Consumption of enough calories to sustain training levels along with consumption of enough individual macronutrients to sustain the type of training/exercise you are performing (This is an individualized thing based on type of training, fitness goals, etc)
  4. Adaptability! Listen to your body. If you are feeling tired, beat up, etc, take it easy. If you are feeling full of piss and vinegar, get after it. Be able to adapt your training program (individually or through a coach) from day to day based on how you are feeling. A potentially more accurate way to listen to your body with what is going on physiologically with you is through monitoring your Heart Rate Variability (HRV). You need a heart rate monitor which can easily hook up to an app on your smartphone, such as Joel Jamison’s BioForce HRV or iThlete. If your HRV score is Red, and you have a killer session planned, adjustment of your training program for that day is needed. Utilization of a personal coach, whether remotely or in person, is extremely useful in this regard.
  5. Supplement wisely. This also is highly individualized based on training, goals, diet, etc.

 

Test and stop guessing how YOU should fuel and train to perform YOUR best in life today as well as for your FUTURE SELF!

Contact Coach Debbie Potts here for a discovery call

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top

Help Spread the Word!

Help Spread the Word!

You are on your way to feeling and becoming the best version of yourself! Invite your friends to join you in this journey.  Share our free resources with your friends and family.  We can make an impact together with ‘The WHOLESTIC Method’ approach to transforming the WHOLE you from the inside out to improve health, performance and longevity.

Please fill out this form so we know where to send the FREE eBook

Privacy Policy: We hate spam and promise to keep your email address safe

0 Shares
Share
Tweet
Pin
Share